Best in Billiards Editorial Standards

Our Commitment to Accuracy and Historical Integrity
Best in Billiards is committed to preserving, documenting, and presenting the history of billiards with accuracy, fairness, and respect for the people and organizations that have shaped the sport. Billiards history spans generations in which record keeping varied considerably. Tournament results, championship designations, statistics, dates, biographical information, and other historical details are not always complete or consistent. For that reason, Best in Billiards seeks to distinguish documented information from historical interpretation and to acknowledge meaningful uncertainty when it exists. Our objective is not to create a perfect or final account of billiards history, but to contribute responsibly to its preservation.
Research and Sources
Best in Billiards seeks to rely upon credible and independently verifiable information whenever reasonably available. Research may include official tournament and governing-body records, contemporary newspapers and periodicals, established billiards publications, books, historical archives, organizational and manufacturer records, interviews, photographs, programs, advertisements, biographies, and other relevant primary and secondary sources. When multiple sources are available, greater weight is generally given to contemporaneous documentation, official records, established publications, and information that can be independently corroborated.
Personal recollections and later accounts can provide valuable historical information, particularly when formal records are limited, but they are considered within the context of other available evidence.
Conflicting and Incomplete Historical Records
Not every question in billiards history has a definitive answer. Historical sources sometimes disagree regarding dates, tournament results, championship status, statistics, prize amounts, high runs, participation figures, and other details. Earlier periods of the sport are particularly susceptible to incomplete records and conflicting accounts.
When credible sources disagree, Best in Billiards seeks to identify the account most strongly supported by the available evidence. When uncertainty remains significant, the appropriate approach may be to acknowledge that uncertainty rather than present a disputed claim as established fact.
Historical Context
Billiards has changed considerably over more than two centuries. Equipment, rules, tournament structures, professional opportunities, transportation, prize money, media coverage, sponsorship, governing organizations, depth of competition, instructional resources, and recordkeeping have all evolved. For that reason, historical figures and accomplishments should be understood within the circumstances of their respective eras. Modern statistics and standards can provide useful information, but they should not automatically be imposed upon periods in which the opportunities and conditions of competition were fundamentally different.
Editorial Independence
Best in Billiards is an independent recognition and historical research project. Editorial coverage and historical interpretation are intended to reflect available evidence and historical significance rather than advertising relationships, commercial interests, personal popularity, social-media following, or outside pressure.
Governmental, organizational, or media recognition documented by Best in Billiards does not constitute an endorsement of Best in Billiards rankings or selections unless such an endorsement is expressly stated by the organization or official involved.
Editorial Content and Award Selections
Historical coverage and Best in Billiards award selections serve different purposes. Inclusion in an article, historical survey, timeline, profile, or other editorial feature does not constitute a Best in Billiards award or ranking. Likewise, the absence of an individual or organization from an award category should not be interpreted as a judgment that the individual or organization lacks historical importance. Best in Billiards award selections are governed separately by the criteria and methodology described in our Evaluation Standards. This distinction allows the historical record to remain broad and inclusive while maintaining defined criteria for awards and recognition.
America’s First 250 Years
In conjunction with the 250th anniversary of American independence, Best in Billiards developed American Billiards: A History of the Cue Sports in the United States, 1776–2026. The project examines billiards across two and a half centuries, including the development of American games, players, championships, manufacturers, equipment, poolrooms, organizations, media, popular culture, instruction, and professional competition. The project is intended as a historical survey and reference resource. It recognizes that billiards history continues to develop as additional records, archives, photographs, publications, and other primary materials become available.
Corrections and Updates
Historical research is an ongoing process, and Best in Billiards welcomes credible corrections and additional documentation. When reliable new evidence demonstrates that published information is inaccurate or materially incomplete, content may be corrected, clarified, or expanded. Proposed corrections should be supported whenever possible by documentation such as contemporary publications, official records, archival materials, photographs, tournament records, organizational documents, or other independently verifiable evidence. Corrections are evaluated according to the strength of the supporting evidence rather than the prominence or identity of the person submitting them.
Attribution
Best in Billiards recognizes the important work performed by historians, journalists, authors, photographers, researchers, publications, governing organizations, manufacturers, collectors, and others who have preserved the historical record of billiards. When material originates from another identifiable source, Best in Billiards seeks to provide appropriate attribution consistent with the nature and use of that material. The purpose of Best in Billiards historical work is not simply to reproduce existing histories, but to organize, contextualize, preserve, and expand access to information about the sport.
A Continuing Historical Record
No single historian, publication, organization, governing body, or website can provide the final word on more than two centuries of billiards history. Best in Billiards therefore views its historical work as a continuing contribution to the record—one that can be refined as additional evidence becomes available and that encourages further research into the people, events, institutions, innovations, and traditions that shaped the game.